‘Unbelievable’, ‘strange’ and ‘frustrating’ – is VAR letting Premier League down?

Antonio Conte felt Tottenham defender Emerson Royal was wrongly given a red card in his side’s defeat at Arsenal

The Premier League returned on Saturday with its usual cocktail of drama, excitement and controversy – with refereeing decisions and VAR once again a big talking point.

Following his side’s 3-1 defeat by Arsenal, Tottenham boss Antonio Conte suggested refereeing and VAR in England is not at the required level, having seen his player Emerson Royal sent off for a second-half foul on Gabriel Martinelli.

Elsewhere, Crystal Palace chairman Steve Parish questioned the point of VAR, while Fulham boss Marco Silva fumed at what he called “strange decisions”.

“In England, I have to be honest, it is very difficult because there isn’t the same line,” said Conte.

“Sometimes you see a situation that could be a red card and instead is a yellow card or no yellow card, sometimes you see a situation that is a yellow card and you see a red card.”

Here, BBC Sport takes a look at the decisions which created most debate.

Conte unhappy with Emerson red card

Conte was infuriated by the decision to send Emerson off in the 62nd minute with Arsenal leading 2-1.

“They have to work a lot about this,” said the Italian while discussing the standard of refereeing in England.

“In Italy, they go on Thursday and stay together for three days to work together, to look at the video and try and improve.

“I don’t know if they do that in this country, but it would be a good idea because the level is so high and we need the level of the referee and VAR the same.

“The Premier League is a really high level, and for this reason every part of this situation has to be top.”

Speaking on BBC’s Final Score though, former Aston Villa striker Dion Dublin said Emerson deserved a red card.

“No anger or malice, but I still think it’s a red,” said Dublin. “The ball has gone and he has caught him above the calf. I think it’s a red.”

‘Unbelievable how he managed to stay on the field’

At Selhurst Park, Conor Gallagher scored a brilliant late winner to give Graham Potter his first victory as Chelsea boss – but Crystal Palace manager Patrick Vieira was left vexed by a key decision in the first half.

Vieira felt Chelsea defender Thiago Silva should have been sent off after the Brazilian deliberately knocked the ball out of Jordan Ayew’s path with his hand.

When contacted by BBC Sport, a Premier League spokesperson said the officials gave Silva yellow instead of red as they felt he did not deny Ayew an obvious goalscoring opportunity.

Vieira, however, saw it differently.

“I just find it unbelievable how he managed to stay on the field,” Vieira said of Silva, who went on to tee up Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang for Chelsea’s equaliser.

During the game, Palace chairman Parish expressed his frustration at the decision.

However, speaking on BT Sport, Robbie Savage felt referee Chris Kavanagh was right to show Silva a yellow card.

Savage said: “Silva was not denying a goalscoring opportunity, he was going away from goal and so it was the right decision. Silva is the big talking point in the game, but I think the referee got it right.”

‘These decisions feel strange to us’

Another manager to be left unhappy by a key decision in his game was Fulham’s Silva, who watched his side play the majority of the 4-1 defeat by Newcastle with 10 men after Nathaniel Chalobah’s eighth-minute red card.

Referee Darren England initially showed Chalobah a yellow for his challenge on Sean Longstaff, but upgraded his decision to a red after VAR intervention, prompting Silva to call for consistency.

“The referee was clearly there. He told me it was a clear yellow card. After so long a time to find one picture of Nathaniel’s tackle, it is difficult for me to accept,” said Silva.

“If it will always be like that, I would accept it. But I am 100% sure that in moments like that, one will be a yellow card and that’s it.

“This is the difficult situation to understand. We need to see consistency in these situations or you have to give the yellow card.

“I think in the next few weeks in tough matches you will see moments like this one where it will be a yellow card. These decisions feel strange to us.”

Darren England reviews Nathaniel Chalobah's challenge on the pitchside monitor
Referee Darren England upgraded Nathaniel Chalobah’s yellow card to a red after reviewing the incident pitchside

Premier League referees show fewer red cards, says study

Prior to this weekend’s games, a study by data specialists Nielsen Gracenote found that Premier League referees on average show fewer red cards than other major European leagues.

The study found that red cards are awarded at a rate of one every 338 fouls in the Premier League, in stark contrast with the top flights in France (58), Germany (127), Italy (114) and Spain (77).

In the past six Premier League seasons, red cards have been awarded at a rate of between 164 and 209 fouls per sending-off, so while still early in the season, they appear to be more lenient this term.

The leniency on red cards is striking, given that a yellow card is shown once every 5.25 fouls in the Premier League, the second-strictest behind Spain’s La Liga (4.96).

Referees in England were also found to have awarded far fewer fouls (1,350) than other leagues.

A bit of praise…

While some managers were left frustrated, Brentford boss Thomas Frank praised inexperienced referee Thomas Bramall’s “character and calm head” after he stuck to his decision not to award Bournemouth a penalty for Kristoffer Ajer’s challenge on Jordan Zemura, despite being referred to the pitchside monitor.

“I’d like to praise Thomas Bramall for his job today. He’s a young referee, and every Premier League game is important,” said Frank.

“His character and calm head was important in a very, very stressful moment, when you’re called over to the monitor.

“It’s a decisive decision for the game, and nine times out of 10 most likely it’s a penalty.

“But he sticks to his decision and that says a lot about him. I’m not in doubt that’s not a penalty, so very well done for him.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like